ConsumerReports.org
 
September 2006
Ratings Antispam

 

Microsoft
Allume systems
  Microsoft Allume Systems


Availbility Most products at stores through October 2006.
Within types, in performance order.  indicate Quick Picks. Products with equal scores are listed alphabetically.
Excellent
Very good
Good
Fair
Poor
Quick picks Product Price Annual fee Overall score Test results Features
 

 












 

E-MAIL PROGRAMS Sometimes bundled with new computers; filter spam without additional software.

Microsoft Outlook 2003

$100 None
87.
•     •  

Apple OS 10.4.6 Mail

130 None
83.
• •   •  
 

ADD-ONS Used in conjunction with an e-mail program to recognize and filter spam.

Trend Micro Anti-Spam Pilot (stand-alone version)

Free None
95.
•     •  

Allume Systems SpamCatcher

30 $10
85.
• • • •  
 

Cloudmark Desktop

40 40
81.
•   •    
 

Trend Micro Anti-Spam (suite version)

50 25
76.
•     • •
 

PC Tools Spam Monitor

30 20
71.
• •   •  
 

BitDefender SpamDeny

20 15
56.
• •   • •
 

McAfee SpamKiller

40 30
51.
      • •
 

Symantec Norton Anti-Spam (suite version)

70 40
48.
• •   • •
 

Sunbelt Software iHateSpam

20 10
11.
• • • •  
 

Blue Squirrel Spam Sleuth Pro

30 None
10.
  •   •  
 

CA/eTrust Anti-Spam

30 20
10.
• •     •


Guide to the Ratings

Overall score is based on the ability to recognize valid e-mail and spam. Delivers valid e-mail indicates how well a product correctly identified e-mail that wasn’t spam; excellent products correctly identified more than 95 percent. Poor ones misidentified at least 20 percent. Detects spam indicates how well each product correctly identified spam. A product that integrates with mailer blends its own controls with those of the e-mail program. One that learns identifies patterns in your e-mail, if you tell the software which messages are spam and which are not. With online collaboration, a product checks each message against a “live” online database of reported spam messages to improve accuracy. Rules-based filters detects known attributes, such as whether it contains a suspicious link. Also in suite means similar software is available in the mfr.’s security software suite. All products let you add “friendly” and “unfriendly” senders to the filter (either automatically or manually). Price is for the retail, boxed version. Some products are available via download, with a free trial period of at least 15 days. (Most will mail a CD for a few dollars.)