September 2007 printable version

Ratings Antivirus programs



Trend Micro AntiVirus plus AntiSpyware (PC-cillin Internet Security 2007)
Trend Micro AntiVirus plus AntiSpyware
(PC-cillin Internet Security 2007)
Check Point ZoneAlarm Antivirus (Internet security Suite 7.0)
Check Point ZoneAlarm Antivirus (Internet security
Suite 7.0)
Alwil Avast Home Edition 4.7
Alwil Avast Home Edition 4.7



Availability
 Programs are periodically updated.
New versions should perform at least as well
as the version we tested.
In performance order based on test results.

indicates Quick Pick.
Excellent
Very good
Good
Fair
Poor
  Product Price Service Overall Score Test results Features


renewal fee/yr.
number of PCs
detection
features
ease of use
scan speed
scheduled scan
IM scan
rootkit detection
firewall

Trend Micro AntiVirus plus AntiSpyware (PC-cillin Internet Security 2007)

$40 $40 1
81.
• • • •

Check Point ZoneAlarm Antivirus (Internet Security Suite 7.0)

30 20 1
79.
• • • •
 

Microsoft Windows Live OneCare (Vista) 1.5

50 50 3
76.
•     •
 

BitDefender Antivirus (Internet Security) 10

30 22 1
75.
• • • •
 

McAfee ViruScan Plus (Internet Security Suite) 2007

40 40 1
74.
• • • •
 

Symantec Norton Antivirus (Internet Security) 2007

40 40 1
67.
• • • •
 

Kaspersky Labs Anti-Virus 6.0

50 35 1
65.
•   • •
 

Symantec Norton Antivirus for Macintosh 10.1

50 50 1
63.
• • •  
 

F-Secure Anti-Virus (Internet Security) 2007

66 66 3
62.
•   • •
 

CA/eTrust Antivirus 2007

50 30 3
60.
•      

Alwil Avast Home Edition 4.7

free none -
55.
  •   •
 

Grisoft AVG Anti-Virus Free 7.5

free none -
53.
•      



Guide to the Ratings

Product shows the name of the stand-alone product and, in parentheses, the name of the security suite that contains the same product, if available. The stand-alone and suite versions of that component should be equally effective. Overall score is based mainly on detection, with features, ease of use, and scan speed also considered. Detection is how well the product detects current and new viruses without falsely identifying benign files as viruses. Our tests used both real viruses captured during testing and variants of real viruses we developed using the techniques that real virus writers use. Some scores differ from 2006 results due to changes in scoring and updates to the tested program. Features reflects the usefulness of the program's features. Ease of use indicates convenience. Scan speed is how quickly the product scans a typical hard drive. Scheduled scan means you can set up automatic scans. IM scan shows whether the product scans instant messages. Rootkit detection indicates protection against this especially insidious malware. Firewall indicates whether there are features to block hackers. Price is for the download version and includes the first year of service. Boxed versions are usually available for about $10 or $15 extra.



For our antivirus and antispyware tests, we enlisted help from Independent Security Evaluators (ISE), a computer-security consulting firm. ISE’s president, Avi Rubin, is a former technical advisory board member of a company acquired by software vendor McAfee before ISE began work for Consumer Reports. He continues to act as an adviser to that company and was not involved in our testing.