printable version
Ratings Security suites  September 2008

BitDefender Internet Security 2008
BitDefender Internet Security 2008
McAfee Internet Security Suite with SiteAdvisor
McAfee Internet Security Suite with SiteAdvisor
A free suite (Avira AntiVir Personal Edition, Microsoft Windows Defender, SPAMfighter Standard)
Free Software from Avira, Microsoft, and SPAMfighter




Availability
 Most models at stores through December 2008.
Listed in order of overall performance.  (Note: to see whole chart use scroll bar below.)

indicates Quick Pick.
Excellent
Very good
Good
Fair
Poor
  Product Price Overall score Antivirus Anti-badware Antispam Suite considerations
  
BitDefender Internet Security 2008 $50 $50
80.
• • •     •     •   • •       •
McAfee Internet Security Suite with SiteAdvisor 50 40
80.
• •   • • • •       • • •   • •
  Kaspersky Internet Security 7 80 56
78.
•   • • •   •   • • • •       •
  Trend Micro Internet Security 2008 50 50
78.
• • • • •     •     • •   •   •
  Check Point ZoneAlarm Internet Security Suite 50 50
75.
• •   • •     •   • • •   •   •
  Symantec Norton Internet Security 2008 60 50
74.
• •     • • •       • •   •    
  Microsoft Windows Live OneCare 50 50
74.
          •       •     •   •  
  F-Secure Internet Security 2008 80 60
73.
•   • • • • •       •         •
A free suite
Avira AntiVir Personal Edition Classic 7
Microsoft Windows Defender
SPAMfighter Standard


free


free


60.
Avira


 

 


•
Microsoft



•


•

 
SPAMfighter


 


•

 
All three combined




             
  CA Internet Security Suite Plus 2008 70 50
55.
•   •   • •     • • • • •     •
  PC Tools Internet Security 2008 60 60
53.
•     • •   •   •              
 Discontinued; replaced by Free Antivirus 8, which claims enhancements.


GUIDE TO THE RATINGS

Overall score reflects the ability to detect viruses, spyware, adware, and spam without falsely flagging nonthreats. Some scores differ from last year’s results due to changes in the 2007 versions of software and to tests and scoring. Antivirus performance mainly reflects detection of current and new viruses, with features, ease of use, and scan speed also considered. E-mail scan allows automatic removal of viruses from e-mail; IM scan, from instant messages. Easy temporary disable pauses protection when you’re installing software. Antibadware performance mainly reflects ability to block installation of known and new spyware and adware, based on threats identified by StopBadware.org, an organization of which CU is a member. Features and ease of use are also considered. Some programs protect browser settings from threats. Threat details means you get information to help you decide whether a detected file is actually bad. Threat info to manufacturer means you can easily notify about flagged files. Anti­spam performance primarily reflects recognition of valid e-mail and spam without tagging good e-mail as spam. Features and ease of use are also considered. Some programs work with non-Microsoft e-mail programs. Some use online collaboration to check messages against a "live" online database for added accuracy. Some check on suspicious links and other spamlike attributes with a set of rules and/or learn from past spam results. Suite features scores overall array. Ease of use reflects installation, configuration, and day-to-day use. Resources measures load on PC memory, processor, and hard drive in a scan. Under suite considerations, ad/popup blocker suppresses those annoyances. A child filter can block access to certain Web sites. A privacy filter checks e-mail and Web forms and alerts you if you’re about to inadvertently divulge personal information. File backup provides periodic backup to another drive. Wi-Fi monitor signals attempts to access your wireless network. Windows cleanup is a convenient interface for many maintenance functions. An Internet "off" button cuts access if a malicious file is suspected. Price is for the downloaded version and includes the first year of service. Boxed versions are usually available for $10 to $15 extra.